New Documentary Takes on Women’s Work & Worth

="NYT

Twenty Feet from Stardom, the documentary currently playing in DC-area theaters about backup singers, is on its surface a stereotypical Hollywood tale: ingénue steps into the recording studio seeking fame and fortune, but comes up short – in this case, an achingly close 20 feet short.

It is also, of course, about so much more. It’s about the people – overwhelmingly women of color – whose names you don’t know but who are responsible for the best parts of your favorite songs – the voices with whom you have sung along for years. It’s also about the chances artists – and particularly women artists – take when their career trajectories lie in the hands of the Ike Turners and Phil Spectors of the world (even if you haven’t seen the film, you can imagine how that might turn out). Finally, 20 Feet from Stardom is an exploration of the dreams we have for our lives and what happens when they come up short – at least in the eyes of others.

A number of people interviewed for the film, for example, assumed that Lisa Fischer (who has sung backup for the Rolling Stones, Luther Vandross and Sting, among others) wants and should have an incredible solo career. At a time when we’re so focused on celebrity, on leaning in and on having it all, this seems to be a logical assumption. But if you ask Lisa, she’d likely say that she already has it all. And she’d probably have some interesting things to say about what “having it all” means. In the film, Lisa makes it clear that she has everything she wants – and when she went for some prize that everyone else thought she should have, she discovered that it made her miserable.

Darlene Love had her a-ha moment decades after singing back-up for artists that included Frank Sinatra, Sam Cooke and Elvis. After a career that was tightly controlled and limited by Phil Spector, Darlene left the industry and took on work cleaning houses for $100 a week. One day, while cleaning someone else’s bathroom, one of her old songs came on the radio and she stopped and asked herself what she was meant to do. Her answer: “God gave me this talent and I intend to use it.” She asked a couple of friends for a loan and returned to music – only this time she had her own strategy and controlled her own image. After taking any gig she could find, she worked her way up to Broadway and into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.

Most of us cannot imagine what it’s like to be a backup singer, but the experiences and emotions portrayed in 20 Feet from Stardom are universal. I think that many of us can share the feelings of being unrecognized, of not having enough control, or not living up to expectations – whether they’re our own or others’. And that’s when it’s time to listen to the advice given by Dr. Mable John (a former Raelette who sang backup for Ray Charles): “…we need to know our worth; we need to know, as women, we’re important. I think the breakdown is when a woman doesn’t know what she is and she settles for less.”

It’s a lesson that works just as well off stage as on. The fascinating, devastating stories featured in 20 Feet from Stardom are unique because of their glamorous setting, but the lessons associated with them are not uncommon. The women in the film seemed to be happiest and most satisfied when they had control over their own lives, when they were getting recognition for their accomplishments and when they were fairly compensated. These are, of course, “no duh” statements – a fact that makes it seem even more criminal that they were denied these things to begin with, and a reminder that it’s incumbent upon all of us to make sure that we value ourselves and one another fairly.

Photo from NYTimes.com.

Weekly Round-Up: News and Analysis on Women and Poverty (Week ending April 15, 2009)

Spotlight on Poverty and Opportunity, a national foundation-led initiative, is excited to collaborate with Washington Area Women’s Foundation to bring you the latest news and analysis on women and poverty.

Spotlight is the go-to site for news and ideas about fighting poverty.

For daily updates and links to past articles, check out “Women and Poverty.” It’s a new section of our site with a comprehensive collection of recent news and analysis on women and poverty.

Along with these daily updates, continue to visit TheWomensFoundation.org for our weekly rundown of the top news stories on women and poverty every Friday.

Here’s this week’s news:

• An editorial appearing in the Chicago Sun Times argues that more support for single moms will benefit the next generation.

• The Washington Times profiles a Washington, D.C. resident who is known for her charity work with low-income mothers.

• In an op-ed for the Pittsburgh Post Gazette, a contributor in favor of Notre Dame’s controversial invitation to President Obama argues that he disapproves of bishops’ support of pro-life candidates, which he believes has led to a widening of the gap between rich and poor.

• As reported in the Atlanta Journal Constitution, several clinics for low-income patients, including a women and children’s center, are slated to close in Georgia.

• The Detroit News reports that Michigan’s cuts of certain programs may hurt its chances of receiving federal matching funds allocated to low-income mothers and pregnant women.

• A Milwaukee Journal Sentinel commentary on a low-income clinic struggling to stay open notes that most of its clientele is single mothers and their children.

• A USA Today piece on stimulus funds going to Indian tribes notes the benefits it will provide to people like Naomi Sitting Bear, a mother living with her family in dilapidated housing, as well its support for domestic violence programs.

• A Chicago Tribune piece on new housing for homeless and low-income residents interviews a woman, recently released from jail, who believes that the housing will provide her with new stability and opportunities.

• The Miami Herald reports on a disabled woman who was given housing from Habitat for Humanity on Mother’s Day.

• The Governor of Rhode Island has proposed a plan that would cut state aid to low-income pregnant women, as noted by the Associated Press.

To learn more about Spotlight, visit www.spotlightonpoverty.org.  To sign up for our weekly updates with the latest news, opinion and research from around the country, click here.

The Spotlight on Poverty and Opportunity Team

Spotlight on Poverty and Opportunity is a foundation-led, non-partisan initiative aimed at ensuring that our political leaders take significant actions to reduce poverty and increase opportunity in the United States. We bring together diverse perspectives from the political, policy, advocacy and foundation communities to engage in an ongoing dialogue focused on finding genuine solutions to the economic hardship confronting millions of Americans.

News roundup: The Women's Foundation's new president!

The media has been abuzz with talk of Phyllis Caldwell and her appointment as president of The Women’s Foundation. 

To read more about Phyllis, her goals for The Women’s Foundation and her background, check out these recent news articles and blogs:

D.C. Examiner: "Three Minute Interview: Phyllis Caldwell"  (Live link)  (PDF)

Washington Business Journal: "Bank of America exec heads to nonprofit"

Washington Post Regional Briefing: "Women’s Foundation Names Chief"

Washington Grantmakers Daily: "Washington Area Women’s Foundation announces new president"

Philanthropy News Digest: "People in the News (12/02/07): Appointments and Promotions"

Washington Times: "Movers and Shakers"

News on Women: "Phyllis Caldwell Caldwell Made President of The Washington Women’s Foundation"

Congrats Phyllis!  We’re all looking forward to working with you!

Marjorie Sims speaks out on WAMU!

On Labor Day, Marjorie Sims took to the airwaves on WAMU, during the Diane Rehmwoman with drill Show, to offer a powerful commentary on the importance of investing in nontraditional pathways to opportunity for women in our region. Hear her speak out.

Then, tune in on Friday, September 14 at 6:35 and 8:35 a.m. to hear Marjorie’s commentary on women’s empowerment on 88.5 FM WAMU.

NWEF: Women, write on.

It seems timely that while I sat in a media training this weekend sponsored by the National Women’s Editorial Forum, a little discussion bubbled up over the blogosphere and elsewhere about the lack of respect granted to women’s voices in the media. 

First, there are the recent studies showing that there is a lack of women and minority-owned media (As of 2006, women of all races owned five percent of the 1,400 commercial broadcast television stations in America, while people of color, who make up 33 percent of the national population [and will be more than 50 percent by 2050), owned 3.6 percent.  For radio, a study released this month shows that women and minorities own six and 7.7 percent of all broadcast radio stations in the country respectively.).

Then, there is the discussion on Katie Couric, and whether she is getting a fair shake as the first female anchor of network television, or whether she’s unfairly being laid blame to the downfall of evening news while her male counterparts consistently push off "real news" to proritize stories like the current one on Paris Hilton’s jail time. 

As a follow-on, Jennifer Pozner is asking whether Mocking Women Journalists is a Prime-time Sport, in her blog about Fox news’ new reality show, Anchorwoman, which will "feature a busty blonde bikini model and former WWE wrestler as an on-air anchor of KYTX Channel 19, a local CBS affiliate in Tyler, Texas." 

And, of course, there has been all the serious talk of late about sexual harrassment prevailing on the blogosphere towards women, and all the flack Siu Lang Panoke (a graduate student at American University), took when she wrote that Economic Status Should Not Hinder Higher Education.  Sadly, some of the reaction didn’t center so much on the arguments she made, but were attacks against her for being a single mother. 

Anyway, you can see where, in the interest of contributing to the part of our mission that is to raise the voices of women and girls, I felt this training–Power Tools for Contemporary Media: Building Women’s Presence in the Commentary Continuum–might be of value.

With fewer than 20 percent of op-eds nationwide written by women, among a number of other stark realities–many of which are referenced above–the National Women’s Editorial Forum "empowers women to engage in, transform and democratize the media landscape and is dedicated to increasing the supply of comentary by women and their participation in the media."

Write on. 

The training brought together talented leaders such as the President of NOW in New Jersey, members of Code Pink and leaders of local organizations such as Ohio’s Hard Hatted Women, among many others.  We were trained up to improve our skills in writing op-eds, creating radio pieces, being interviewed on television and participating to the fullest extent possible in the blogosphere to raise our own voices, and those of the organizations and causes we work for.

(Yes, we are tired.) 

In exchange for motivation and inspiration from the likes of Eleanor Clift, Josephine Reed, Ann Friedman and Laura Rogers,  we were asked simply to write, speak and blog–as individuals and as part of organizations working on behalf of women–on issues of note and importance to women.

An important note for everyone–women, nonprofits, philanthropists, and citizens concerned with and working on behalf of women, girls and better communities–to take the personal reactions we have to the news and what we see in the world around us and to put it into words and out there, for the public, to consider, digest, debate and eventually, act on.

Just as Siobhan noted earlier, there is power in making philanthropy public–particularly for women–and a significant piece of this isn’t just to put our money where our mouths are, but to use every mouth piece available to raise our voices.

A scary challenge, but also an important one.

So women, write on. 

To learn more, or to submit an op-ed as a female voice, or on women’s issues, through the National Women’s Editorial Forum–or one of the state editorial boards in your state (they’ll help you place it)–learn more here.